Canucks vs. Oilers: Arturs Silovs or Casey DeSmith, who's your ...

Can you really change your goalie after a win?

Article content

To hear Vancouver Canucks coach Rick Tocchet talk about it Thursday, he may do that.

Article content

Arturs Silovs started Game 1 for the Canucks, a 5-4 win over the Edmonton Oilers.

But after a trio of strong performances to help guide his team to a first-round series win over the Nashville Predators, he was far from convincing in Game 1 against Edmonton.

He struggled with tracking the puck. Even if you set aside each of the four Edmonton goals for one reason or another — screens, deflections — you can point to the moments like in the third period where a pass went through his legs and nearly went in the net.

Too often he was slow in his reads and poorly executed his positioning.

Vancouver Canucks goalie Arturs Silovs looks on during a stoppage in play during the second period in Game 1 of an NHL hockey Stanley Cup second-round playoff series against the Edmonton Oilers, in Vancouver, on Wednesday, May 8, 2024. Photo by DARRYL DYCK /THE CANADIAN PRESS

And so his coach didn’t shy away from a question about where his process is at for who will start in goal for Vancouver on Friday at Rogers Arena. Silovs or could it be Casey DeSmith, who played in Games 2 and 3 against Nashville before suffering a mysterious injury that put Silovs in the crease for Game 4.

Article content

Silovs is the incumbent, the coach admitted. But …

“He’s earned the right, right now, to play, but that doesn’t mean you know, we haven’t officially made a (decision),” Tocchet said. “The one thing we have: We have Casey, and Casey competed. You know, he could play tomorrow.”

Whatever the injury was, Tocchet said he thought DeSmith was back to 100 per cent.

“I think he’s past it, so he is definitely a viable option for us,” he said.

Vancouver Canucks head coach Rich Tocchet at team game-day team practice at Rogers arena Tuesday, April 23, 2024. Photo by Jason Payne /PNG

How’s that for hockey-fan fodder for the next 24 hours or so?

In the big picture, who plays in goal for Vancouver isn’t that important, unless it’s Thatcher Demko.

Demko is clearly the better goalie. His season, with a Vezina Trophy nomination, is testament to this.

It’s not just that he’s taller than both Silovs and DeSmith, it’s that he is more agile and simply a more talented game reader.

Article content

Article content

But he’s not here, out with a suspected knee injury, still unlikely to play before the end of the current series.

Whether it’s DeSmith or Silovs in goal, the real story will be determined by how the Canucks defend in front of their goalie.

The way they defended against Connor McDavid on Wednesday was case in point — for the first time in his NHL career, McDavid didn’t record a single shot on goal in a playoff game.

The world’s greatest player was kept in check.

The towering duo of Carson Soucy and Tyler Myers had a lot to do with that, but so did J.T. Miller’s line.

With Myers or the Miller line on the ice against McDavid, the Canucks took about two-thirds of the shot attempts. That’s not the kind of figure you are used to seeing for McDavid.

Article content

Soucy said Thursday that much of this success was down to the up-ice work by the Canucks’ forwards. They were quick to take space away from McDavid and his teammates, he said.

“I think our forwards all night just did a good job of kind of being in front of them while they’re trying to wind up their speed,” he said.

Vancouver Canucks goaltender Arturs Silovs (31) and defenseman Carson Soucy (7) celebrate the team’s 4-3 overtime win against the Nashville Predators in Game 4 of an NHL hockey Stanley Cup first-round playoff series Sunday, April 28, 2024, in Nashville, Tenn. Photo by George Walker IV /AP

Tocchet has long harped on his forwards to defend by skating forward, to take away the space rather than give it up.

McDavid, of course, thrives with even an inch of space and through one game, anyway, the Canucks did well at that.

Soucy said the Canucks did a good job of limiting the Oilers to one-and-down opportunities when they did gain the zone.

Rather than allowing repeated chances on rebounds, the Canucks smartly collected the puck and then turned play back up ice.

Article content

It’s how they overcame giving up four goals.

That’s not a great recipe for long-term success, of course, but the Canucks made it work on this night.

But in Game 2, they can’t expect to win again 5-4.

And that brings us back to Silovs and DeSmith.

Whomever starts must put in a credible performance. There are going to be terrible bounces, you can’t control those.

Control the things you can. Manage your crease. Be quick to set up and face the threat.

Tocchet said he would be meeting with Canucks director of goaltending Thursday afternoon, to go over what they see from Silovs on Wednesday and to determine if they should stick with the young netminder or swap back to the veteran DeSmith.

And until then, we’ll just have to wait, and ponder.

Article content

[email protected]

Read more of our Canucks vs Oilers Round 2 playoff coverage:

• Vancouver vs. Edmonton: Here are 8 things each city is ‘winning’ • Canucks vs. Oilers: Arturs Silovs or Casey DeSmith, who’s your goalie for Game 2? • Canucks vs. Oilers: Kindergarten class in Carson Soucy’s Alberta hometown is divided on series • Canucks viewing parties: Here’s where to watch the Canucks vs. Oilers Round 2 playoffs • 5 crucial questions facing the Canucks in Round 2 • Could Thatcher Demko really play vs. the Oilers? • Canucks vs. Oilers: All a bloodless rivalry needs is a playoff series • ESPN seems to hate Vancouver • Canucks this week, playoff edition: Underdogs against the Oilers — just the way we like it • Pearl Jam leaves Vancouver with special Canucks message • Like Rocky Balboa, Arturs Silovs wants to go distance against Stuart Skinner • After half a century on the back burner, might Oilers-Canucks rivalry finally be heating up? • How Pius Suter makes the Miller line go from good to dominant • ‘I can’t stand’ it: Canucks coach Rick Tocchet tired of embellishment in playoffs • Underdogs? Quinn Hughes ‘prepared to play my best hockey’ • J.T. Miller on matching up against Connor McDavid: ‘He’s different than anybody’ • Unplugging Edmonton’s potent playoff power play is top priority

Article content

Recommended from Editorial

Canucks 5, Oilers 4: Getting off the playoff mat to land incredible knockout punch

Stanley Cup Coffee: Canucks vs. Oilers goalie jitters — but for who? — and Edmonton's defensive nightmares

Canucks vs. Oilers: Kindergarten class in Carson Soucy's Alberta hometown is divided on series

ROUND 2! SIGN UP TO GET YOUR FREE CANUCKS PLAYOFF POSTERS: We are proud to partner with the Vancouver Canucks to bring you this year’s edition of the longtime Province tradition, the Canucks Playoff Poster series. CLICK HERE to get a new player poster emailed to you every game day, plus all the posters from Round 1!

Article content